Cold Brew Coffee Makers That Are Actually Worth Buying

9 min read

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate and eBay Partner Network publisher, we earn from qualifying purchases. This doesn’t affect what we recommend or how we describe it.

Most home cold brew coffee makers brew between 32 and 64 ounces per batch—a crucial range that affects both how much coffee you get and how much fridge space you’ll need. If you’re short on counter or refrigerator space, or just want to make a single cup at a time, picking the right size can save you daily hassle. But it’s not just about capacity: filter design, ease of cleanup, and price all play a big role in how much you’ll actually enjoy using your brewer week after week.

Top picks at a glance

Mr. Coffee Wrenley Cold Brew Maker — best for beginners
Takeya Patented Deluxe Cold Brew Coffee Maker Black — the budget pick
Primula Pace Cold Brew Iced Coffee Maker — the most compact choice

Spot the difference between the top cold brew coffee makers

Three products stand out for cold brew at home: the Mr. Coffee Wrenley Cold Brew Maker, the Takeya Patented Deluxe Cold Brew Coffee Maker Black, and the Primula Pace Cold Brew Iced Coffee Maker. Each is aimed at a different kind of coffee drinker, from beginners looking for a foolproof process to budget-focused buyers and those with limited space. Here’s how they stack up.

Pictured: Mr. Coffee Wrenley

Product	Condition	Price	Best For	Capacity (oz)	Footprint (inches)
Mr. Coffee Wrenley Cold Brew Maker	New	$$	Beginners	64	7.5 x 7.5 x 10.1
Takeya Patented Deluxe Cold Brew Coffee Maker Black	New	$	Budget pick	32	5 x 7.5 x 9.5
Primula Pace Cold Brew Iced Coffee Maker	New	$$$	Compact choice	51	7.2 x 5.2 x 9.5

$ / $$ / $$$ indicates budget / mid-range / premium relative to the picks above. Check live listings further down for current prices.

Choose the right cold brew maker for your needs

All three models make smooth, low-acidity cold brew at home, but they’re not interchangeable. Here’s what sets each apart—and which one fits your routine best.

Mr. Coffee Wrenley: Best for beginners

The Mr. Coffee Wrenley Cold Brew Maker is designed for simplicity. Its 64-ounce capacity stands out: you can brew enough concentrate for several days, which is ideal if you want to cut down on daily prep. The Wrenley uses a built-in filtration system that’s designed to minimize grit and simplify cleanup, a big plus if you’re new to cold brew and want to avoid messy grounds in your cup. The footprint (7.5 x 7.5 x 10.1 inches) is on the larger side, so make sure your fridge shelf can handle it. Compared with the other two, the Wrenley sits in the mid-price tier, which gets you a more robust build and a smoother brewing process, but it isn’t the cheapest or the smallest option out there.

Takeya Deluxe: The budget pick

The Takeya Patented Deluxe Cold Brew Coffee Maker Black is all about value. At the lowest price tier, it gives you a solid 32-ounce brewing capacity—enough for one or two people to enjoy fresh cold brew over a couple of days. The Takeya Deluxe is compact (5 x 7.5 x 9.5 inches) and shaped like a pitcher, which makes it easy to fit in most fridge doors. Its filter basket is fine-mesh, which helps reduce sediment, though you’ll want to use a coarse grind for best results. If you want the most affordable way to try cold brew at home, this is the strongest match.

Primula Pace: Most compact

The Primula Pace Cold Brew Iced Coffee Maker is the premium-priced option, but its main selling point is the compact design. With a 51-ounce capacity in a 7.2 x 5.2 x 9.5 inch frame, it strikes a balance between batch size and fridge-friendliness. The Primula Pace uses a borosilicate glass carafe for durability and flavor neutrality, and the filter is easy to remove and clean. If you’re tight on space but want to make more than a single serving at a time, this is the right pick. The premium price reflects the glass build and sleeker look, but if you don’t need those, the Takeya Deluxe covers the basics for less.

Related Guides

How we chose the best cold brew makers for this guide

For this shortlist, the focus was on three key criteria: brew capacity, ease of use and cleaning, and space efficiency. Brew size matters for how often you need to make coffee (32–64 ounces covers most household needs). Filter design and carafe material affect both taste and how much cleanup you face—fine-mesh or metal filters are preferred for reducing grit, and glass or sturdy plastic carafes last longer and don’t absorb flavors.

Each option was compared based on manufacturer specs, stated features, and their intended user profile. Listings that didn’t specify capacity or material, used generic/unbranded parts, or bundled multiple unrelated accessories were excluded to keep the focus on reliable, single-purpose cold brew makers. This guide is built on research—always check the latest listing details before buying.

If you want a machine that can brew hot and cold coffee, or need to serve a crowd, these single-purpose cold brew makers may not be the right fit. For those cases, a larger multipurpose brewer or a commercial setup makes more sense.

Red flags in listings to walk past

No stated capacity: If the listing doesn’t say exactly how many ounces or liters the brewer holds, you’re likely looking at a generic or undersized product.
Unbranded or “OEM” filters: This often means the manufacturer hasn’t invested in quality control. Filters that don’t fit well lead to leaks or gritty coffee.
Stock photos only, no real images: Listings that rely only on polished marketing images might be hiding poor build quality or small actual size. Look for photos showing the product in real-life use.
Vague material claims: If the listing just says “plastic” without specifying BPA-free or food-grade, it could be made from lower-quality plastics that affect taste or durability.
Bundled with unrelated extras: If you see a cold brew maker packaged with random tools or kitchen gadgets, it’s often a tactic to distract from a mediocre main product.

When you want a brand-new unit with the full warranty, Amazon’s catalogue is usually the deepest.

See similar picks on Amazon →

Cold brew maker FAQs

How much coffee can I make with these brewers at once?

The Mr. Coffee Wrenley holds up to 64 ounces, the Takeya Deluxe brews 32 ounces, and the Primula Pace fits 51 ounces. For most households, that covers 4 to 8 servings per batch, depending on your preferred strength and cup size.

How long does cold brew concentrate stay fresh in the fridge?

Properly stored cold brew concentrate lasts up to 7–10 days in the fridge. For best flavor, keep it sealed and avoid leaving the filter or grounds in the liquid after brewing. Glass carafes like the Primula Pace help preserve taste longer than plastic.

Which cold brew maker is easiest to clean?

By design, the Mr. Coffee Wrenley focuses on easy cleanup with a removable filter system. The Takeya Deluxe and Primula Pace both use fine-mesh filters that rinse clean, but the smaller opening on the Takeya can make scrubbing the inside more fiddly. If you hate cleaning, the Wrenley is the strongest match.

Takeya Deluxe vs Primula Pace—best for small fridges?

The Takeya Deluxe is the most compact in both width and depth, fitting easily in most fridge doors. The Primula Pace is slightly larger but offers a bigger batch size. Go with the Takeya if every inch counts, or the Primula Pace if you want to squeeze out a few more servings per brew.

Can I use pre-ground coffee or do I need to grind my own?

All three brewers work best with coarse ground coffee, which helps prevent clogging the filter and reduces sediment. While you can use pre-ground coffee, most store-bought pre-ground is too fine for cold brew. If possible, grind your own beans on the coarsest setting for smoother results.

Is the higher price of the Primula Pace justified over the Takeya Deluxe?

The Primula Pace costs more mainly for its borosilicate glass carafe, larger capacity, and more refined design. If you value durability, flavor neutrality, and a sleeker look, it’s worth the difference. For pure function at the lowest price, the Takeya Deluxe is the better value.

What if the filter or carafe breaks?

Replacement parts availability varies by brand. The Mr. Coffee Wrenley and Primula Pace both have established manufacturer support, making it easier to find spare filters or carafes. For the Takeya Deluxe, check if the seller lists official replacement parts or direct support channels before buying.

Why cold brew is different: brewing, taste, and caffeine content

Cold brew relies on a long steep (usually 12–24 hours) with cold water, which extracts fewer bitter compounds and acids than hot brewing does. This typically results in a smoother, less acidic cup with a different flavor profile and a higher caffeine concentration per ounce of concentrate. For more on the science and health research behind cold brew, see the National Coffee Association.

The bottom line: which cold brew coffee maker should you choose?

If you want a set-it-and-forget-it brewer that’s easy for anyone to use, the Mr. Coffee Wrenley is the clear winner for beginners and batch brewers. For the lowest price and maximum fridge space savings, the Takeya Deluxe is hard to beat. And if you care about design, durability, and a slightly larger capacity in a compact package, the Primula Pace justifies its premium tier. No matter your pick, you’ll get a smoother, more refreshing cup of coffee—without the daily coffee shop run.

Still not sure? Browse more cold brew coffee makers here to compare even more options.

Related Guides